Both Sides on Zero Tolerance
Today student violence in schools has gotten out of control. As a result school systems have been forced to put zero tolerance programs in effect. Some may feel school systems have been out of control in enforcing these policies. There appears to be no flexibility when determining consequences for students. Administrators must follow the proper procedures and there must be consistent discipline. With all the bullying, stalking, harassment, fights, and hurtful behavior students are inflicting on each other something had to be done to address this serious issue.
Numerous people are debating both the pro and con issues of a zero tolerance policy. Many feel that good kids that make a mistake just once should not be as severely punished as the student that is always getting in trouble. However, others feel when the same rules apply to everyone, students will realize they will face penalties. There must be no tolerance for inappropriate and sometimes illegal behaviors.
Rich-Shea teaches crime and justice studies at University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth, and is a fellow at Suffolk University’s Center for Restorative Justice. She states, “With zero tolerance, what had been kids’ defiant behavior became assault. In schools, bullying, fighting and sexual harassment are now criminalized. Research shows that these harsh, punitive policies have a negative effect on school climate and reduce academic achievement.” (Shea)
Others feel that the “one strike, you’re out” policy is not too harsh. These people feel that an example must and should be set. An article by Sean McCollum states, “Rule-abiding students deserve safe, drug-free environments in which to pursue their studies. Classmates with problems need to be removed and given the help they need” (McCallum).
In order to rectify part of this problem, administrators, school personnel, and parents must establish guidelines and follow them. Proper training about zero tolerance should be provided by school systems. At least this way everyone can understand the ramifications of what is considered improper and inappropriate behaviors. Everyone will also understand the consequences and this training will put everyone on the same page.
No comments:
Post a Comment